Header Logo
Services Physical Therapy Return to Run Program Courses Blog
About Contact
Log In
← Back to all posts

If You Can Never Trust When a Run Is Going Well...

Jul 24, 2026
Connect

There's a common pattern you might be experiencing if you have a running injury...

  1. You have pain during a run (or several runs).

  2. You do all the "right" things: rest, recover, maybe stretch or do some exercises.

  3. A few days later, you run again and it feels okay. Maybe several runs go well.

  4. Then, seemingly out of nowhere, the pain comes back.

  5. Repeat the cycle.

If this sounds familiar, you're not alone.

It's one of the most common stories I hear during consultation calls.

The hardest part isn't always the pain itself. It's what it does to your confidence. Every time you start to think you're finally past it, the pain returns. Eventually you begin questioning every good run, wondering if it's only a matter of time before the next setback.

So why does this happen?

The answer is rarely just one thing. Running injuries are usually influenced by a combination of your training, your strength, your recovery, and your body's current ability to tolerate those demands. That's why there's rarely a simple, one-size-fits-all fix.

One of the concepts we use in sports medicine is called load capacity.

Think of it like developing a callus.

The first time you spend hours raking leaves or lifting weights, your hands might become sore or even blister. But with repeated exposure, and enough time to recover, your skin adapts by becoming thicker and more resilient.

Your muscles, tendons, and bones work in a very similar way.

Running places stress on your body. Given the right amount of stress, enough recovery, and good nutrition, your tissues adapt and become more capable of handling future runs.

That's the entire purpose of training. We don't get fitter by avoiding stress. We get fitter by recovering from it.

Problems arise when the stress consistently exceeds what your body is prepared to handle. That can happen if training increases too quickly, recovery is inadequate, strength isn't keeping pace with your running, or several smaller factors add up over time.

That's when pain often enters the picture.

Take this slide from my Runner's Checklist Course as an example.

Running and strength training are the stressors that tell your body to adapt. Sleep, nutrition, and recovery are what allow those adaptations to actually happen. When those pieces stay in balance, your body's capacity grows. When they don't, you may repeatedly exceed what your tissues can currently tolerate.

The goal isn't to avoid stress altogether.

Just like you wouldn't want to remove every callus from your hands if you work with them every day, you also don't want to eliminate all loading from your body. A healthy amount of stress helps your tissues stay strong. The key is finding the right amount. Enough to build capacity without repeatedly pushing beyond it.

So if you've tried all the "safe" things like resting, icing, stretching, or random exercises but you still find yourself stuck in this cycle, there may be a missing piece.

This is exactly where many runners in the Return to Run Program started.

If you're ready to understand how to strategically balance your running, strength training, and recovery so you can build confidence instead of guessing what your body will do next, I'd love to chat.

I'm currently offering 15% off the Return to Run Program through August 1st. Reply to this email or book a consultation call to see if it's the right fit for you.

Questions about this topic? Just hit reply to start the conversation.

—
Dr. Erin Kennedy Dalisay, PT, DPT, OCS
Doctor of Physical Therapy & Run Coach

Responses

Join the conversation
t("newsletters.loading")
Loading...
This Is Your Captain Speaking
It's human nature to crave certainty and relief.  Most runners first encounter physical therapy in pain and therefore seeking relief. Naturally, they hope the clinican they're paired with during an initial evaluation has the certainty to match. Unfortunately, that's not always how it pans out. Recently I was remembering how I had an existential crisis right before my graduation from physical th...
There Are No Magic Exercises, Just Smart Timing
If you’ve ever stayed up late googling the answer to your pain with running, you might’ve run into some contradictory advice!  It’s like when we had our first daughter and were reading all the Reddit posts about the best methods to get her to sleep through the night.  We searched for one perfect method.  Some magic answer to save the day when it all seems uncertain.  Some golden nugget of gleam...
Highway to the Danger Zone
East Coast runners - let's talk about the Extreme Heat Warning. We're missing the Virginia heat wave this weekend as we're back in Sacramento visiting family and I've heard this song on the radio at least four times in the last two days. It's stuck in my head, but seemed like a good title to talk about the heat while running. Every summer this comes up, but it's worth repeating.  Always err on ...

For the Long Run

A weekly newsletter exploring how to keep runners strong, healthy, and injury-free through every season of life. Blending personal insight with evidence-based strategies from my background in physical therapy and coaching—because running well is about more than just mileage, pacing and races. Running is for life.
Footer Logo
Services Physical Therapy Return to Run Program Courses Blog

The 4 Essential Exercises for Runners

FREE: The 4 exercises I give ALL my runners (download now)